Tiered Rate Traps: How Banks Advertise 5% But Pay You 0.25%
That eye-catching APY on the banner ad? Read the fine print. Many banks use tiered rates to bait you with high numbers you'll never actually earn.
The Bait & Switch: What You See vs. What You Get
What Is a Tiered Rate Structure?
A tiered rate structure means the APY you earn depends on meeting certain conditions—typically a minimum balance, direct deposit, or both. Miss the threshold, and your rate crashes.
Banks love tiers because they can advertise the highest possible rate while knowing most customers won't qualify for it. It's technically legal, but it's designed to mislead.
The Worst Offenders
CIT Bank Platinum Savings
Drop below $5,000 for even one day, and your entire balance earns 0.25%. That's a 94% rate cut.
Varo Bank Savings
Requires $1,000+ monthly direct deposit AND only applies to your first $5,000. Amounts over $5,000 earn just 3.00% regardless.
SoFi Checking & Savings
A 75% rate reduction if you can't or won't set up direct deposit. The ads prominently feature "4.00% APY" while the 1.00% base rate hides in footnotes.
LendingClub High-Yield Savings
Skip one month of deposits and your rate drops to virtually nothing. The worst penalty rate we've seen.
Why This Matters: A Real Example
Let's say you open a CIT Bank Platinum Savings with $10,000. You're earning that nice 4.10% APY—$410/year.
Three months later, your car breaks down. You need $6,000 for repairs. You withdraw it, leaving $4,000 in the account.
Your rate instantly drops to 0.25%. On $4,000, you now earn $10/year instead of $164/year. That's $154 in lost interest—on top of an already stressful situation.
Worse, even after you rebuild your balance above $5,000, you've lost months of higher interest you'll never get back.
The Psychology of Tiered Rates
Banks use tiered rates strategically because they know:
- Optimism bias: When opening an account, you assume you'll always meet the threshold. "I'll just keep $5,000 in there—easy!"
- Life happens: But eventually, you'll face an emergency, a large purchase, or just forget to monitor your balance.
- Switching costs: By the time you realize you're earning 0.25%, you've already set up automatic transfers, linked accounts, and it feels like too much hassle to switch.
The bank wins either way: if you meet the threshold, they're paying competitive rates. If you don't, they're paying nearly nothing while keeping your deposits.
How to Spot a Tiered Rate Trap
Before opening any account, ask these questions:
🔍 Questions to Ask Before Opening
- 1. What's the BASE rate? The rate with zero requirements. This is what you'll earn if life gets complicated.
- 2. What are the tier thresholds? Know exactly what balance or activity is required for each rate tier.
- 3. What happens if I dip below? Is the penalty immediate? Does it apply to my whole balance or just the amount below threshold?
- 4. Can I realistically meet requirements long-term? Be honest with yourself. If you can't commit to $5K+ for years, choose a flat-rate account.
Banks With Clean, Flat Rates (No Tiers)
These banks pay the same rate on every dollar, no requirements:
Notice that even flat-rate accounts at 3.70% beat tiered accounts where you're earning the penalty rate of 0.25%.
The Bottom Line
Tiered rates aren't inherently bad—if you can genuinely maintain the threshold forever. But for most people, a flat-rate account provides more predictable, reliable returns without the anxiety of monitoring balance requirements.
When comparing accounts, always compare the BASE rate, not the advertised rate. That's the rate you'll earn when life doesn't go according to plan.
And life rarely goes according to plan.
Find flat-rate accounts with no traps
Compare savings accounts that pay the same rate on every dollar.
Compare Accounts